SCT has watched with interest the ongoing debate around the
future of the Union Terrace Gardens in Aberdeen. After Aberdeen
City Council decided in favour of transforming the gardens into a
'civic square' a design competition was launched, and it was
recently announced that the public could be asked to take part in
the city's first local referendum to finally decide the future of
Union Terrace Gardens.
The Trust has now commented to highlight the importance of a
full understanding of the historical development, and significance,
of the Gardens as part of any assessment of the shortlisted
designs. The following letter was published in the Aberdeenshire
Press & Journal on Tuesday 14th June 2011.
To Editor, The Press and Journal
For Publication
Dear Sirs
Opinion remains divided on the controversial plans to
transform Aberdeen's Union Terrace Gardens into a new public
space. However, it makes sense to allow the current design
competition to run its course - at least to the point of making
public the shortlisted designs - before passing comment on their
suitability and quality. Union Terrace Gardens, in their
present form, make a positive contribution to the heart of the
city and the conservation area. Before major change is
proposed, it would be wise to ensure that the historical
development of the gardens, and their cultural
significance, are fully understood.
In accordance with recommended planning policy a
conservation area character appraisal has been prepared.
It was approved by the Council in 2007 after a period of
public consultation and sets out clear guidance for the
enhancement of the gardens by stating that 'Maintaining the
openness of the space and its natural valley landform is of primary
importance to any redevelopment or enhancement scheme'. The
conservation area character appraisal will be a material
consideration in the planning process, and this should not be
overlooked when determining the outcome of the design
competition.
Yours sincerely
John Pelan
Director, Scottish Civic Trust